Open access protocol comparing the validity of the modi. The ashworth scale was originally developed in 1964, and modified by bohannon and smith in 1987. Testretest and interrater reliability kappa kappa value of the modified tardieu scale. The more famously used tool found in the practice is the ashworth scale or the modified ashworth scale, 15. Pdf comparison of modified ashworth scale and hoffmann. Modified ashworth scale mas model based on clinical data measurement towards quantitative evaluation of upper limb spasticity.
Comparing the validity of the modified modified ashworth. Scale and modified ashworth scale in acute stroke patients. Slight increase in muscle tone, manifested by a catch and release or by minimal resistance at the end of the range of motion when the affected parts is moved in flexion or. It is a quick and easy measure that can help assess the efficacy of treatment. The mas measures resistance during passive softtissue stretching. The ashworth rates tone on a scale of 04, while the modified ashworth was developed to further define the lower end of the scale making it more discrete by adding. Ashworth scale modified ashworth scale rehabmeasures database. Slight increase in muscle tone, manifested by a catch and.
The modified ashworth scale does not comply with the concept of spasticity a velocitydependent increase in muscle tone scholtes, 2007 the modified ashworth scale measures muscle tone intensity at one, unspecified, velocity which can make comparisons difficult scholtes, 2007. Existing translations can be obtained from mapi research trust. Research article comparison of modified ashworth scale. May 26, 2016 the modified ashworth scale does not comply with the concept of spasticity a velocitydependent increase in muscle tone scholtes, 2007 the modified ashworth scale measures muscle tone intensity at one, unspecified, velocity which can make comparisons difficult scholtes, 2007. The mas is a quick and easy measure that can assist a clinicians assessment of spasticity during passive softtissue stretching. The modified ashworth scale yielded reliable measurements in the lower limb for a single examiner, and agreement was best on the grade of 0. Tardieu scalemodified tardieu scale rehabmeasures database. Measuring the effectiveness of interventions is accepted as being central to good practice. The tardieu scale differentiates contracture from spasticity whereas the ashworth scale is confounded by it. The modified ashworth scale mas is a valid test of spasticity beverly billi cusick, pt, ms, cndt, cof when jw lance 1980 inserted the words muscle tone into his description of spasticity as a velocitydependent. However, due to its inherent subjectivity, interevaluator discrepancies arise. Introduction reliable and valid tools must be used to assess spasticity in clinical practise and research settings. Comparing the validity of the modified modified ashworth scale mmas and the modified tardieu scale mts in the assessment of wrist flexor spasticity in patients with strokeprotocol for a neurophysiological study.
Place the patient in a supine position if testing a muscle that primarily flexes a joint, place the joint in a maximally flexed position and move to a position of maximal extension over one second count one thousand one if testing a muscle that primarily extends a joint, place the joint in a. Shoulder, elbow, wrist, hip, knee and ankle spasticity were assessed by the use of modified tardieu scale and modified ashworth scale data collection procedures. Interrater reliability of a modified ashworth scale of muscle spasticity article pdf available in physical therapy 672. Mehrholz j1, wagner k, meissner d, grundmann k, zange c, koch r, pohl m. What does the ashworth scale really measure and are.
The resistance is scored from 0 to 4 ashworth scale and from 0 to 5 modified ashworth scale. The modified ashworth scale mas measures resistance during passive softtissue stretching and is used as a simple measure of spasticity. Grading is always performed at the same time of day, in a constant position of the body for a given. We each independently graded the elbow flexor muscle spasticity of 30 patients with intracranial lesions.
To assess intra and interrater reliability of the modified ashworth scale mas. Tardieu scale this scale quantifies muscle spasticity by assessing the response of the muscle to stretch applied at specified velocities. Pdf interrater reliability of a modified ashworth scale of. The modified ashworth scale mas measures resistance during passive softtissue stretching. The ashworth scale and mas measure spasticity and are applied manually to. As 2 but with minimal resistance through range following catch 3. Purpose of the measure the modified ashworth scale is considered the primary clinical measure of muscle spasticity in patients with neurological conditions. However, some publications question its ability to measure spasticity and advocate the modified ashworth scale as a rating scale to measure abnormality in tone or the resistance to passive movements, since there continue reading. Pdf interrater reliability of a modified ashworth scale. Ashworth and modified ashworth scale mas assessment overview assessment area icf domain.
In the mmas, spasticity is scored on an ordinal scale from 0 to 4 as follows. Reliability of measurements obtained with the modified. The reliability between examiners was not good, which may bring into question the validity of measurements obtained with the scale. Jan 28, 2018 this video is about modified ashworth scale. Place the patient in a supine position if testing a muscle that primarily flexes a joint, place the joint in a maximally flexed position and move to a position of maximal extension over one second count one thousand one. However, the validity of this scale has been challenged. One quick and easy way to measure spasticity is the modified ashworth scale mas. The mas is done in supine this will garner the most accurate and the lowest score. Reliability of ashworth and modified ashworth scales in children with spastic cerebral palsy. In the assessment of spasticity, methods that are easily used in practice are. The kendalls tau correlation between our grades was. Published in 2006, the modified modified ashworth scale aims to improve the reliability of the modified ashworth scale. Modified ashworth scale and spasm frequency score in.
Therefore, there are systems that quantitatively evaluate spasticity. An additional grade summary the ashworth scale is a measure of spasticity originally developed to. General information derived bohannon and smith, 1987 place the patient in a supine position. Grading is always performed at the same time of day, in a constant position of the body for a given limb. Apr 10, 2008 in the assessment of spasticity, methods that are easily used in practice are. Reliability of the modified ashworth scale and modified. The mas is performed in the supine position this will garner the most accurate and the lowest score as any. In order to retrieve relevant publications the authors performed. Thus, the relationship between the raters judgments was significant and the reliability was good. To assess the reliability of the modified ashworth scale mas and modified tardieu scale mts in patients with spinal cord injuries scis. For each muscle group, reaction to stretch is rated at a specified stretch velocity with 2. Pdf modified ashworth scale mas model based on clinical data.
The validity and reliability of the mas is questionable and therefore critically discussed throughout literature. Slight increase in tone with a catch and release or minimal resistance at end of range 2. Modified ashworth scale rl muscle under stretch score the modified ashworth scale 0. The purpose of the modified ashworth scale is to measure spasticity in patients who have lesions of the cns or neurological disorders. Reliability of the modified tardieu scale and the modified. The ashworth or modified ashworth scale mas is a measure of spasticity developed as a simple clinical classification to assess the antispastic effects of carisoprodol in multiple sclerosis. Reliability of the tone assessment scale and the modified ashworth. Ashworth scale with all of its variants remains the standard with which other measures of spasticity are compared. The reliability of the tone assessment scale was not as strong as the modified ashworth scale, with marked variability in the assessment of posture. This page presents the best available information on how outcome measures for stroke might be classified and selected for use, based upon their measurement qualities.
There is a paucity of literature regarding the validity of the modified modified ashworth scale mmas and the modified tardieu scale mts. General information derived bohannon and smith, 1987. Jan 01, 2002 the modified ashworth scale yielded reliable measurements in the lower limb for a single examiner, and agreement was best on the grade of 0. The scale measures the resistance and spasticity or catch in the joint during passive movement. The mas is performed in the supine position this will.
The modified ashworth scale is the most commonly used measurement tool to evaluate spasticity in adults and cpchildren. Ashworth scale mas is the most routinely used instrument in clinical practice to assign spasticity levels. The ashworth scale 4, bohannonsmith modified ashworth scale 5, and tardieu scales 69 are currently used to measure spasticity. Complete disaster full interior car detailing transformation. No study, to date, has been performed to compare the validity of the mmas and the mts. Key messages reliable and valid tools must be used to assess spasticity accurately in clinical and research settings. Our provide team will get back to you with the needed information and license agreement in a timely manner. This scale quantifies muscle spasticity by assessing the response of the muscle to stretch applied at specified velocities. Tardieu scale velocity to stretch v quality of muscle. Jun 10, 2009 one quick and easy way to measure spasticity is the modified ashworth scale mas. Reliability of the modified tardieu scale and the modified ashworth scale in adult patients with severe brain injury. The clinical import of the ashworth scale has not been well established and is, in part, enmeshed in the controversy as to whether spasticity has a signi. Ashworth and modified ashworth scale mas spinal cord. Interrater reliability of a modified ashworth scale of.
Reliability of the tone assessment scale and the modified. Test retest and interrater reliability kkappa value of the modified tardieu scale and the modified ashworth scale. The modified rankin scale mrs is a commonly used scale for measuring the degree of see alsoedit. We undertook this investigation to determine the interrater reliability of manual tests of elbow flexor muscle spasticity graded on a modified ashworth scale. Modified ashworth scale instructions general information derived bohannon and smith, 1987. The ashworth scale is the most widely used assessment tool to measure resistance to limb movement in a clinic setting, although it is unable to distinguish between the neural and nonneural components of increased tone. Intraobserver reliability of modified ashworth scale and modified tardieu scale in the assessment of spasticity in children with cerebral palsy. Jan 05, 2016 this feature is not available right now. Currently the modified ashworth scale is the one most in use but the original version of 1964 stays as its basis, although it originates as a monitoring scale of the antispastic effect of medication rather than a patient oriented scale.
1558 223 143 754 470 242 1567 903 130 1225 1439 545 1225 1466 187 871 23 1170 289 135 1266 1 547 1457 881 146 269 1556 1589 494 1221 445 1630 884 51 1162 1098 534 325 879 1263 669 808 1229 1495 687 969